FRL
RemediesS.D.N.Y.· filed 2024-05-23

33 States v. Live Nation / Ticketmaster, antitrust monopoly (remedies phase)

Potential forced divestiture of Ticketmaster from Live Nation, venue sell-offs, fee caps, and structural breakup of the live-music industry's dominant vertically integrated conglomerate; billions in consumer damages.

Latest development

On August 4, 2026, Judge Subramanian denied without prejudice the states' bid for discovery into the DOJ's settlement with Live Nation, writing in a one-page order that 'the Court has no actual requests for testimony or documents to review, and so the precise scope of what the states are asking for is unclear.' He directed the states to serve 'narrow and targeted' requests on the DOJ and Live Nation, told both to 'entertain these requests in good faith,' and signaled that discovery in the Tunney Act review is legally available when kept within reasonable bounds. Separately, he heard argument on Live Nation's post-trial Rule 50(b) and Rule 59 motions on July 31 and has not ruled; at that hearing he pressed the states hardest on the amphitheater market definition and the promotion tying claim, while also questioning Live Nation's statute-of-limitations theory and its attempt to discount evidence of threats and conditioning. Remedies discovery remains stayed until those motions are resolved.

Tracker entry updated 2026-08-07

Background

The Department of Justice filed an antitrust lawsuit against Live Nation Entertainment and its Ticketmaster subsidiary in May 2024, alleging the company illegally monopolized the live entertainment industry through a vertically integrated web spanning concert venues, artist management, concert promotion, and primary and secondary ticketing. Thirty-three states and the District of Columbia joined as co-plaintiffs. The DOJ settled separately with Live Nation in March 2026 for $280 million, without requiring Ticketmaster's divestiture, but the states continued to trial on their own claims.

On April 15, 2026, a federal jury in the Southern District of New York found Live Nation and Ticketmaster liable on all counts, concluding they had unlawfully monopolized primary concert ticketing services and amphitheater markets and had tied their venues to concert promotion services. The jury calculated damages at $1.72 per primary concert ticket sold under the anticompetitive conduct. The case now enters a remedies phase: the states are seeking structural relief including forced divestiture of Ticketmaster, sale of Live Nation amphitheaters, unwinding of exclusive booking agreements, and consumer restitution. Key briefing runs through summer 2026; a remedies trial is not expected before February 2027, with an appeal widely anticipated.

Why It Matters for Artists and Fans

Live Nation's vertical integration has long been criticized by artists and independent promoters who say the company can effectively coerce artists into using Ticketmaster by controlling the venues those artists need to tour. A forced breakup would be the most significant restructuring of the concert industry in decades, potentially opening the market to competing ticketing platforms, reducing service fees, and giving artists and independent venues more negotiating power. Even short of a breakup, the verdict's per-ticket damage finding could expose the company to billions in aggregate liability from ongoing and future anticompetitive conduct.

Primary sources

  1. [1]Live Nation Asks Judge to Undo Monopoly Verdict, Claiming Jury Followed "Emotional Arguments" Over Law, TicketNews (2026-07-06)
  2. [2]Live Nation and Ticketmaster ask court to throw out monopoly verdict, or grant new trial, Music Business Worldwide (2026-07)
  3. [3]Live Nation, States Clash Over New Antitrust Ruling Before Post-Trial Hearing, TicketNews (2026-07-27)
  4. [4]States grilled on market definition concerns in Live Nation case, Global Competition Review (2026-07-31)
  5. [5]Judge Probes Evidence Behind Live Nation Monopoly Verdict, Leaves Ruling Pending, TicketNews (2026-08-03)
  6. [6]Judge Denies States' Discovery Request Into Live Nation Settlement, Leaves Door Open, TicketNews (2026-08-06)
  7. [7]Just Toss It? Live Nation Moves to Invalidate Entire Antitrust Verdict in USA v. Live Nation, Digital Music News (2026-07-06)
  8. [8]States Fight Live Nation Bid to Undo Monopoly Verdict as New Filing Details White House Settlement Talks, TicketNews (2026-06-19)
  9. [9]Live Nation Discloses That CEO Spoke With Trump Before Surprise Antitrust Trial Settlement, Variety (2026-06-18)
  10. [10]Trump, Live Nation CEO spoke before antitrust case settlement: Filing, The Hill (2026-06-18)
  11. [11]Live Nation Wins Pause on Breakup Discovery While It Tries to Undo Monopoly Verdict, TicketNews (2026-06-03) [archived]
  12. [12]Jury finds Live Nation and Ticketmaster operated as a monopoly and overcharged fans, CNN (2026-04-15) [archived]
  13. [13]After the Verdict: Navigating the Live Nation/Ticketmaster Antitrust Fallout, Crowell & Moring (2026-04-16) [archived]
  14. [14]States Seek Ticketmaster Breakup, Live Nation Venue Selloffs After Monopoly Verdict, TicketNews (2026-05-15) [archived]
  15. [15]How Live Nation Verdict May Affect Ticket Prices, Time (2026-04-16) [archived]
  16. [16]Ticketmaster-Live Nation monopoly verdict impact on ticket prices, NPR (2026-04-16) [archived]

Source pack

Reporting on this? Every claim above maps to these primary sources.

  1. [1]Live Nation Asks Judge to Undo Monopoly Verdict, Claiming Jury Followed "Emotional Arguments" Over Law, TicketNews, 2026-07-06
  2. [2]Live Nation and Ticketmaster ask court to throw out monopoly verdict, or grant new trial, Music Business Worldwide, 2026-07
  3. [3]Live Nation, States Clash Over New Antitrust Ruling Before Post-Trial Hearing, TicketNews, 2026-07-27
  4. [4]States grilled on market definition concerns in Live Nation case, Global Competition Review, 2026-07-31
  5. [5]Judge Probes Evidence Behind Live Nation Monopoly Verdict, Leaves Ruling Pending, TicketNews, 2026-08-03
  6. [6]Judge Denies States' Discovery Request Into Live Nation Settlement, Leaves Door Open, TicketNews, 2026-08-06
  7. [7]Just Toss It? Live Nation Moves to Invalidate Entire Antitrust Verdict in USA v. Live Nation, Digital Music News, 2026-07-06
  8. [8]States Fight Live Nation Bid to Undo Monopoly Verdict as New Filing Details White House Settlement Talks, TicketNews, 2026-06-19
  9. [9]Live Nation Discloses That CEO Spoke With Trump Before Surprise Antitrust Trial Settlement, Variety, 2026-06-18
  10. [10]Trump, Live Nation CEO spoke before antitrust case settlement: Filing, The Hill, 2026-06-18
  11. [11]Live Nation Wins Pause on Breakup Discovery While It Tries to Undo Monopoly Verdict, TicketNews, 2026-06-03 [archived]
  12. [12]Jury finds Live Nation and Ticketmaster operated as a monopoly and overcharged fans, CNN, 2026-04-15 [archived]
  13. [13]After the Verdict: Navigating the Live Nation/Ticketmaster Antitrust Fallout, Crowell & Moring, 2026-04-16 [archived]
  14. [14]States Seek Ticketmaster Breakup, Live Nation Venue Selloffs After Monopoly Verdict, TicketNews, 2026-05-15 [archived]
  15. [15]How Live Nation Verdict May Affect Ticket Prices, Time, 2026-04-16 [archived]
  16. [16]Ticketmaster-Live Nation monopoly verdict impact on ticket prices, NPR, 2026-04-16 [archived]